CSU campuses fail to return cultural artifacts and remains to native tribes
California State University campuses across the state failed to return human remains and cultural artifacts to Native tribes, disregarding an existing law called Assembly Bill 389, the California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act of 2001.
The act, known as NAGPRA, and its 2001 California counterpart, established requirements for the repatriation of Native American artifacts to Native tribes by government agencies.
Sonoma, Sacramento and San Francisco are a few of the twelve CSU campuses that failed to repatriate any artifacts or remains to the tribes, according to a report released by California state auditor Grant Parks.
Overall, only 6% of the collections have been repatriated to tribes, the report stated.
Among the CSU campuses that failed to return artifacts, only CSU Long Beach has repatriated a majority of its artifacts back to its local Native tribes: Gabrielino/Tongva, Kizh and Acjachemen/Juaneño.
According to the CSU NAGPRA state audit, CSUN, which has a collection of approximately 30,000 artifacts on hand, has failed to repatriate its artifacts back to Native tribes.
Jeffrey Tadór Reeder, Dean of Humanities and Senior Tribal Liaison Officer at CSUN, discussed why human remains and artifacts have not been repatriated at CSUN.
“There is a fairly new law in California that is inspired by Assembly Bill 389, written by James Ramos, who is the only Native American in the State Legislature. It sets a policy where Cal States may not use artifacts for any educational purposes,” Reeder said.
Reeder said that bill 389 encourages CSUs to comply with this law, and CSUN has also reached out to local and regional tribes whose ancestors and cultural heritage may be on campus. CSUN is in communication with several tribes and is continuing to work with them, including the hiring of a repatriation coordinator to coordinate efforts.
California lieutenant governor Eleni Kounalakis called on the CSU Board of Trustees to discuss audit findings on the repatriation of Native American cultural artifacts.
“Undoubtedly, the CSU has fallen short, not only in its failure to comply with NAGPRA and CalNAGPRA but also in its system-level oversight of this process,” Kounalakis said.
Public affairs manager Hazel Kelly, from the CSU chancellor’s office, commented on behalf of CSU Chancellor Mildred García.
“CSU acknowledges that it has fallen short on its responsibilities to repatriate Native American cultural objects and ancestral remains held in university collections through the state and federal mandates,” Kelly said.
The 2023 state audit identified a lack of funding and staffing resources and the absence of a systemwide policy and guidance as the underlying causes of CSU’s lack of NAGPRA compliance. The CSU agreed with the audit and is actively working to fulfill those recommendations.
The chancellor’s office and the individual universities are actively working on implementing the state audit’s recommendations and the state law’s requirements.
This includes completing reviews of its university’s collections and creating a systemwide NAGPRA policy. The CSU is forming a working group of internal and external partners to draft it and will be hosting listening sessions to get feedback from tribal communities throughout the state, which will be incorporated into the policy.
According to the chancellor’s office, each campus will hire a full-time experienced NAGPRA coordinator, creating systemwide campus committees that will have Native American tribal representation in direct consultation with the Native American Heritage Commision. The commission is vetting and confirming all nominations, including a prohibition on using items in CSUN’s collections in teaching and research.
Reeder said CSUN is committed to complying with the state and federal Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Acts.
Latest Daily Sundial
- Gender-inclusive restroom in Maple Hall a “huge step in the right direction” for CSUN studentsMaple Hall opened its doors on March 25 for classes previously held in Sierra Hall, with one of the features of the new building being a multi-stall, gender-inclusive restroom on...
- A day in the life of an esports gamerIt’s 7 a.m. and it’s the day of the Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Tournament at Long Beach State University. After the hour-long drive filled with traffic and getting lost at...
- 2024 NBA playoffs mark the beginning of a new era for the leagueIt’s official, the NBA has entered a new era. The stars and teams who dominated the 2010s are no longer on top. The Golden State Warriors have had their dynasty...
- CSUN holds Veteran Graduation Celebration for class of 2024After a long semester filled with hard work, the 2024 spring term has come to an end. Many students shined through their grit, sacrifice and dedication, including the CSUN student...
- CSUN holds Black Graduation ceremony for class of 2024CSUN hosted its Black Graduation Ceremony Sunday, May 12 at the lawn of the University Library, 52 years after the ceremony was introduced to CSUN. The weather was nice with...
- Life as a parent returning to collegeMy two teenage sons motivate, frustrate, inspire and infuriate me. They make me smile and make me, to use their lingo, cringe. They have watched my return to school, beginning...